Balfour Beatty set to vote against ‘unaccountable’ CITB



Leo Quinn
Leo Quinn

Balfour Beatty has revealed that it is likely to vote against the continuation of the Construction Industry Training Board (CITB) because of a “fundamental weakness” in the training body.

In an article on the firm’s website, chief executive Leo Quinn said the training body has failed to deliver the skilled workers the construction sector requires and the industry “cannot afford to lose another three years” if CITB reforms fail to materialise.

According to Mr Quinn, Britain’s economy demands better value from industry training boards which, he argues, need to have the same accountability as the companies that pay their levies.

The CITB is currently facing its triennial Consensus vote which it needs to win to allow it to continue collecting levy cash from contractors.

But Mr Quinn revealed that Balfour Beatty is planning to vote against Consensus.

“Right now, the Construction Industry Training Board (CITB) is undergoing its triennial Consensus,” Mr Quinn said. “That’s a vote by all those businesses that pay its costs, to agree it has their support to collect its funding Levy from them for another three years. Currently, the CITB occupies a pivotal role in providing all of us in the sector with the skilled workers we need. Bluntly, the present skills shortage shows it hasn’t been doing this for some time.”

He added: “Given that CITB raises £200m a year via the levy, the lack of detail in the information it has provided to date is truly concerning. And were the industry to vote ‘no’ at Consensus and cause the CITB to be wound up, any and all liabilities run up (e.g. pension buy-out)  would fall to the industry to settle – a severe inducement for levy-payers not to exercise that prerogative. Combining the general lack of transparency on strategy, controls and fiscal approach, this is a level of accountability which would be deemed unacceptable in virtually any other public arena in the UK.

“To justify its continued existence alongside the wider Apprenticeship Levy, it must deliver what its Levy-payers – let alone the UK as a whole – critically need: the newly skilled workers to upgrade our infrastructure. Based on the information released by the CITB to date, we have little basis for confidence and strongly believe this it too important to leave to chance.

“Which is why Balfour Beatty is likely to vote against Consensus. Before making a final decision, however, we ask one more time to see detailed information in relation to the reform and governance issues raised above.”

Mr Quinn said: “This is not the first instance of the industry being told CITB will reform itself. This time, we cannot afford to lose another three years if it fails to deliver.”

CITB said it welcomed Leo Quinn’s interest in its governance and performance and that its reforms have wide support from the industry.

Sarah Beale, CEO of CITB, said: “We agree that CITB needs to see through its reforms, and that the industry needs to be able to hold CITB more strongly to account. Reform of CITB has already started and full details of our complete reform plan will be shared in November, ensuring full alignment to the ITB review recommendations.

“Our biggest ever industry consultation held this spring suggests that a majority of firms, including the smaller employers that dominate our industry, broadly welcome CITB’s reforms. These include streamlining what we do to provide better value for levy payers, embracing the modernisation agenda to help all construction firms become more productive, and ensuring that standards, training, support for careers and our reformed grants scheme are in place to meet industry’s key skill needs.

“We have also made it clear that we will work closely with our industry, with employers of all sizes and across Britain, to agree our objectives and to ensure that we are held to account in delivering them. We are confident that a reformed CITB, with active support and challenge from industry, will be well-placed to meet construction’s challenges ahead.”

CITB will publish the results of Consensus at the beginning of November 2017.



Related posts